Some call him the World’s last major progressive leader, others the Messiah but, lately, it seems the halo is beginning to slip from above Justin Trudeau’s head.
Trudeau was widely applauded when, on his election, he famously appointed women to fill half of his cabinet positions. He did it, he said, because it was 2015. It felt like a mini-revolution, a challenge to less-progressive nations to follow suit. Trudeau’s bold move elevated Canada’s international and progressive status in an instant.
When Fascism forced its way into the White House last fall, our film stars, rock singers, and pretty much everyone with their moral compass set to ‘left’, promised to move to Canada overnight. The fact that they are still here only means they intend to bravely fight The New Hitler by our sides.
Two years on from Trudeau’s election, however, we are now in the Current Year, and dissent is growing.
The first to throw stones, as the Guardian reports, is Pamela Palmater of the centre for indigenous governance at Toronto’s Ryerson University. She complains, “Justin is practicing token feminism…He made his cabinet half women, but these are women who are already privileged and in power. So, essentially, he shared some power around a small group of elites.”
We enthusiastically greeted Trudeau’s move at the time, like all progressive publications, including the Guardian. However, like them, we have since changed our minds. We are now surprised and disappointed that Trudeau filled his cabinet with women who only got to their station in life through ‘education’, ‘hard work’, ‘professional backgrounds’ and other elitist credentials. When you look at the profiles of these women, we find variously a former family physician, a medical geographer and former professor at the University of Windsor and University of Toronto, a former deputy editor of The Globe and Mail, a lawyer and former managing partner at the public-relations firm Cohn & Wolfe, and an international trade and competition lawyer. Elitists one and all.
What you do NOT find are the right kind of feminists like the ones pictured below. Nor do we find any transgendered women, aesthetically-challenged women of weight, or any uneducated women from Canada’s indigenous population.


Another glaring failure involved Trudeau’s behaviour when meeting Trump recently. He shamelessly shook Trump’s hand, exchanged some niceties about the weather and his Bryan Adams collection, poured him a coffee, before getting down to business. “How could the prime minister possibly sit down and discuss women in the workforce with President Trump without first denouncing his misogynist comments?” cried Sheila Malcolmson, an MP with Canada’s New Democratic party, in parliament. Quite.
The Guardian quotes Kathryn Trevenen, another progressive academic from somewhere in Canada: “Trudeau’s feminism is a version that is much more palatable to the mainstream …focusing on women who are mostly straight, white, middle to upper class and cisgender. I think that Justin Trudeau’s commitment to feminism comes out of a historically liberal type of feminism, one that often gets called white feminism these days, that focuses on giving rights and privileges to only a very narrow group of women. If someone is going to claim the mantle of feminism, I want them to claim the mantle of that feminist – the intersectional feminism that looks for profound structural change – not the sort of white liberal feminism that involves the assimilation of a few privileged women into institutions of power.”
Powerful words which may come back to haunt Trudeau. Whilst we have not given up all hope yet, Trudeau is officially on notice.





















Leave a Reply
12 Comments on "Justin Trudeau Attacked For Being “The Wrong Kind Of Feminist”"
The bench is thin and the conviction is thinner. When was the last time we lost a liberal by self immolated because we weren’t getting to utopia fast enough?
#hate-speech
You’re a fucking white male!
Jihadi Justin – defender of the rights of Muslims to rape, kill and steal
some people are waking up!
#islamophobic
Thanks, Onan, for spilling your comments under this article.
I heard the Koran is both Eternal and Infallible.
Now how a book put together in Cairo about a 100 years ago can be described as Eternal is a bit strange. Since it is also Infallible and also states that the sun sets in a muddy pool I would like to take a vacation to see the sun setting in that there muddy pool
Seeing such a “unique” sunset would be the event of a lifetime.
Anyone here have directions to that there “muddy pool”?
#islamophobic
Excellent article Pbier. I share the suspicion that Trueau is simply a right wing extremist in disguise. First of all, after centuries of sexism and transphobia, we shouldn’t be putting ANY men in powerful positions. According to identity politics, they simply lack the qualifications, as they are men. Being a womyn IS a qualification, being transgender IS a qualification. We also don’t need any more white politicians or business leaders – they are NOT qualified, since they are white. We need QUALIFIED cabinet members with a range of oppressed identities. The higher up the oppression pyramid you are, the more qualified you are. If Trudeau is serious about creating a just and fair society, he needs to start from the TOP DOWN, and that means NO MORE WHITES!
We should appoint cabinet members according to the social strata they occupy and the proportion of MDM articles dedicated to this strata, because this is the best measure of their contribution to society. On a conservative estimate 30% of articles are about Muslims so they get 30% of positions. Perhaps 25% of articles concern the LGBTQ+ community etc. Again, I’m probably understating the percentages here but you get the idea
That certainly sounds like a valid way to do it, but I think that ultimately this is an issue for CRT scholars to solve. They need to develop a fully accredited oppression pyramid, which allows us to judge how qualified a candidate is based on their identity. Candidates can then submit their resumes detailing every aspect of their identity such as race, gender and sexual orientation, and these attributes will all be used calculate a comprehensive victim score. The whole process can be automated.
Ultimately, every transaction in the economy should be priced according to the oppression pyramid. Say you want to buy a watermelon, a white male would be charged $20 whereas a refugee from Syria would receive a rebate of $10
I agree. The share prices of companies run by oppressed minorities should also be mandated higher than those run by white males. This is the only way to achieve equality.
Additionally, each and every one of us should be mandated to buy at least 80% of goods from minority- and womyn-owned businesses. Government already mandates preferential purchasing from such businesses and gives tax breaks to them, and this is perfectly legal since our Constitution does not prohibit any discrimination against white males. It is sad that private citizens are not fully using the opportunity to boycott businesses owned and operated by WHITE FUCKING MALES.
As usual, government is way ahead: The federal government provides tax breaks for businesses that use minority companies in procuring materials and supplies.
This awful man was actually seen with the demon seed (Ivanka) from Donald Trump last night. Speaking of him here just legitimizes the illegitimate fake lying fascist person who is not my president. Trump must be stopped. He is killing Big Bird with his merciless budget cuts.